← Back to Insights

Section 106 and CIL: Managing Planning Obligations

25–50%
Affordable Housing Requirement
£50–400
CIL Rate per m² (London)
3–9
Months S106 Negotiation
£95/t
Carbon Offset (GLA)

Planning obligations add £50–400 per m² to a residential scheme, with London CIL running £50–400 per m² and affordable housing at 25–50%.

Planning obligations — Section 106 agreements and the Community Infrastructure Levy — can add £50 to £400 per m² to a residential development's cost line. Yet they're frequently treated as a late-stage surprise rather than a modelled cost. For developers, understanding and quantifying planning obligations at appraisal stage is the difference between an accurate residual land value and a costly overpayment for the site.

Section 106 vs CIL: What's the Difference?

Both mechanisms extract financial contributions from development, but they operate differently:

  • Section 106 (S106) is a negotiated agreement between the developer and the local planning authority, attached to the planning permission. It is site-specific and can include affordable housing, education contributions, transport improvements, healthcare, open space, and other obligations tailored to the development's impact.
  • Community Infrastructure Levy (CIL) is a fixed, non-negotiable charge per m² of new floorspace, set by each local authority in its charging schedule. CIL funds strategic infrastructure (transport, schools, green energy) across the authority area, not project-specific mitigation.

Both can apply to the same development. S106 addresses site-specific impacts; CIL addresses broader cumulative impacts. Crucially, CIL cannot double-count what S106 covers — but both can be substantial.

The Affordable Housing Negotiation

Affordable housing is typically the largest single S106 contribution. Requirements vary by authority:

  • London — typically 35–50% affordable housing, subject to the Fast Track Route (if policy-compliant) or Viability Route (if not).
  • South East and major cities — typically 25–40%.
  • Rural and lower-value areas — typically 20–30%, or nil where viability doesn't support it.

The affordable housing percentage is negotiable, but the negotiation is evidence-based. A robust viability assessment — demonstrating that the policy requirement would make the scheme unviable — can reduce the percentage. But the NPPF's strengthened presumption in favour of development means authorities are under pressure to hold the line. Prepare for a fight, and make sure your viability assessment is bulletproof.

Common S106 Contributions

Beyond affordable housing, typical S106 obligations include:

  • Education — per-pupil contributions based on projected child yield from the development. Typically £5,000–£15,000 per primary pupil place and £10,000–£20,000 per secondary place.
  • Transport and highways — sustainable travel contributions, highway improvements, car club membership, cycle parking. Range: £500–£5,000 per unit.
  • Healthcare — per-resident contributions to local GP capacity. Increasingly common; typically £200–£500 per unit.
  • Open space and recreation — on-site provision or off-site commuted sum. £1,000–£3,000 per unit.
  • Biodiversity net gain — mandatory 10% BNG from November 2023. On-site delivery, off-site delivery, or statutory biodiversity credits (£42,000 per unit in 2026).
  • Carbon offsetting — in London, £95 per tonne of CO₂e over 30 years for any shortfall against the carbon target.
Exhibit · NorthEight insight library

The S106 package runs £1,700 to £8,500 a unit — before education or biodiversity

Per-unit planning obligations by component, low and high case, £, 2026 · CIL shown as the final sliver

Per unit, £ · before education or biodiversity credits
Low case
£1,700
High case
£8,500
■ Transport and highways■ Open space and recreation■ Healthcare■ CIL £500
£0£2,000£4,000£6,000£8,000
5× spread on the same unit
Education is per pupil place (£5,000–15,000 primary) and biodiversity credits are £42,000 a unit. Neither is in these bars.
The number that matters
5×spread on the same unit before a single school place or biodiversity credit is counted
Model obligations as itemised lines from day one, not as a flat contingency. Education places and £42,000-per-unit biodiversity credits are the two lines that break appraisals, and neither appears in the headline range.
Source: Town and Country Planning Act 1990 (S106); Community Infrastructure Levy Regulations 2010; London CIL rates and borough schedules as quoted in this article; NorthEight analysis.
A 5× spread on the per-unit package before a single education place or biodiversity credit is counted Low case: per-unit obligations as quoted in the text; final segment: £500 CIL per unit.

The Viability Escape Valve

Where the full S106 package would render a scheme unviable, the developer can submit a viability assessment demonstrating that the return on development value falls below acceptable thresholds (typically 15–20% profit on cost for residential). If the assessment is accepted, S106 obligations may be reduced.

However, the landscape has shifted:

  • Increased scrutiny — local authorities now have dedicated viability officers and access to district valuer support. Optimistic appraisals are routinely rejected.
  • Review mechanisms — many S106 agreements now include review clauses that trigger additional contributions if the scheme outperforms the viability assessment at completion.
  • NPPF changes — the strengthened presumption in favour of sustainable development makes authorities less inclined to accept reduced obligations, as the default position favours granting consent.

Practical Steps Now

  1. Model S106 and CIL in the appraisal from day one — not as a flat contingency, but as itemised cost lines based on the authority's published requirements. Underestimating these is the most common appraisal error we see.
  2. Engage with planning before submitting — pre-application discussions should include S106 heads of terms. Understanding the authority's position early avoids surprises at committee.
  3. Prepare a viability assessment — even if you intend to meet policy requirements, having a viability assessment prepared demonstrates professionalism and provides a fallback if the authority's demands exceed policy.
  4. Check for exemptions and reliefs — first homes exemption, self-build exemption, social housing exemption, and charitable relief can all reduce CIL liability. Many developers miss these.
  5. Factor in S106 monitoring fees — authorities now charge monitoring fees (typically 3–5% of the S106 value) for administering the agreement. Include this in the cost plan.
  6. Programme for S106 negotiation time — 3–9 months from resolution to grant is typical. During this period, interest accrues on the land acquisition. Include it in the finance cost line.

FAQs

What is the difference between Section 106 and CIL?

Section 106 is a negotiated, site-specific agreement attached to the permission, covering affordable housing, education, transport and similar impacts. CIL is a fixed, non-negotiable charge per m² of new floorspace set by each local authority. Both can apply to the same development.

How much do S106 and CIL add to a development?

Planning obligations add £50–400 per m² to a residential development's cost line, with London CIL rates running £50–400 per m². Modelling them as itemised lines from day one, rather than a flat contingency, protects the appraisal — underestimating them is the most common appraisal error.

How much affordable housing is required?

London typically requires 35–50% affordable housing, subject to the Fast Track or Viability Route. The South East and major cities typically require 25–40%, and rural or lower-value areas 20–30%, or nil where viability does not support it. The percentage is negotiable, but the negotiation is evidence-based.

Can S106 obligations be reduced on viability grounds?

Yes, where the full package would render a scheme unviable. The assessment must show return on development value below acceptable thresholds, typically 15–20% profit on cost for residential. Authorities now scrutinise appraisals closely, many agreements carry review mechanisms, and the assessment has to be bulletproof.

How long does S106 negotiation take?

Allow 3–9 months from resolution to grant, which is typical. Interest accrues on the land acquisition throughout that period, so the negotiation belongs in the finance cost line and the programme. Authorities also charge monitoring fees of 3–5% of the S106 value.

Need help modelling planning obligations in your appraisal? NorthEight provides development appraisal, viability assessment, and S106 cost planning services. Get in touch to discuss your project.

Sources

This article is for general guidance only and does not constitute planning or legal advice.

← Back to Insights

Construction Insights & Cost Benchmarking — Free

Practical construction commentary and cost overviews — delivered free, four times a year.

See how we support developers, funders and contractors across the project lifecycle →

Related insights

→ Extension of Time: Managing Delay Claims Effectively → Planning Reform 2026: What It Means for Development → Sustainable Drainage Systems (SuDS): Cost and Planning Impact